Nov 132011
 

About a year ago, I bought a pair of Merrell Chameleon 3 Stretch hiking shoes. I purchased these shoes because I really liked the Chameleon 2 Stretch hiking shoes. The Chameleon 2’s were comfortable on- and off-trail. I used them as my daily use shoes as well. They were the most comfortable and durable shoes I had ever purchased. The shoes were not broken down when I purchased the Chameleon 3’s. The only reason I decided I needed new shoes was because the Chameleon 2’s were starting to look a little ratty. The Chameleon 2’s had a few problems that Merrell fixed in the Chameleon 3’s. First, the topline fabric was prone to tearing, so I ended up having to sew the fabric back down as you can see in the picture. The other problem was that the toe cap became disconnected over time and looked bad. Neither of these things affected the functionality of the shoe.

Merrell remedied these two problems in the Chameleon 3’s by removing the cushy foam that made up the topline and widening the toe cap so that it covered the entire front of the shoe. The thing is, the topline changes and whatever other changes they made altered the way the shoe feels. The Chameleon 3’s are not nearly as comfortable as the Chameleon 2’s. The Chameleon 3’s are also not as practical for hiking. It is very difficult to get them tight on your feet, so they are constantly sliding around and creating blisters. I have not been able to get them tight enough on my feet to prevent this from happening. This did not occur in the Chameleon 2’s. I did a 10 mile hike in the Chameleon 3’s and was left with sore feet and blisters. The Chameleon 2’s were always solid shoes and never did this to me. The shoes are still great and comfortable for everyday use, but I cannot use them for hiking. Another problem I ran into with the Chameleon 3′s is that the elastic cord used for tightening the shoe on your foot quickly wore out and snapped. This was a problem because these things are not easy to replace. You can’t just go to the local shoe store and pick one up, so I had to tie the broken ends together. The Chameleon 2 bungees did not start wearing until late in their life and they never have snapped. I’m sure I could have sent the shoes to Merrell to have the bungees replaced, but they are my daily wear shoes and that would have been a bit of a pain. Overall the Chameleon 3′s just don’t measure up to the Chameleon 2′s.

Chameleon 3 Stretch Rating (1-10; 10 being the best)

Everyday Comfort:               8
Trail Comfort:                        4
Durability:                              9
Hiking Usefulness:               5
Overall Rating (average):    6.5

For this review, I am using shoe terminology that can be found at this website.

Nov 092011
 

Slideshow

I always have a hat whenever I am hiking. It is wide brim and made of synthetic fiber. I underestimated the importance of having a hat only once. This instance was also the only time I ever found myself somewhat lost while hiking. I happened to be hiking in conservation in mid-Missouri. I forgot to bring my hat that day and decided that it was not important to go back and get it. I was wrong. The day was sunny and there was no chance of rain reported by the weather people. It also had not rained in about a week, so I assumed that it was not going to rain. I had four other people with me on the hike and none of them knew how to orienteer or look for forest landmarks. I decided not to bring a GPS since we had a map and compass. All throughout the hike I had been paying attention to landmarks and the map so that I could guide us back when the time came. We had hiked for some time in the conservation area and were ready to head back to the vehicle when a large pop-up storm dumped a deluge of rain on us. The rain quickly covered my glasses and started making them foggy. I tried wiping them down and using my hand to cover them as we walked, but nothing worked. I was effectively blind in the field. Unable to see my landmarks and frustrated, I asked if one of the other group members would be capable of leading the group. One group member stepped up and said that he could do it. Unfortunately, he could not do it. He had not paid attention to the landmarks, so we missed the draw we were supposed to take back to the vehicles and spent hours attempting to look for it. Fortunately, I had followed a cardinal rule of hiking before coming on the hike. I memorized the surrounding area, roads, and trails beforehand. I still had my compass and sense of direction, so we were able to head towards a road that bracketed the eastern side of the conservation area. Once on the road, we were able to easily make our way back to the vehicles. I learned two lessons that day. First, always bring an extra pair of glasses. Second, never forget your hat. If I had my hat, then my glasses would never have gotten wet and I would have been able to see the landmarks and the map. So, be like Aiden in the photo below and come prepared for your hike!

The socks I wear are incredibly cheap, yet effective synthetic athletic socks from the local buy-it-all store. The socks cost about $5 for 3 pairs. They are comfortable and breathable. I have purchased high dollar hiking socks that are not nearly as comfortable as the cheap socks that I use. The brand I purchased was Starter. However, I’m sure there are many other decent brands out there.

I am going to admit up front that I have been using a woefully inadequate pack for my hiking outings for quite some time. The pack I currently use is a cheap Eastport book bag that I picked up during my undergraduate years. The pack provides no support and does not have a frame. It has been the source of many post-hike backaches. The pack that I am thinking about purchasing is an Osprey Stratos series. These packs are very comfortable and provide excellent back support and lots of storage for day hikes. If you are new to hiking, you do not need to invest in an expensive pack. I have gotten by for years with my cheap pack. However, eventually you will want to upgrade.

Stay tuned for part 4, “Hiking Boots.”

Nov 092011
 

At first, I hesitated to write a series that included a discussion of clothing to wear while hiking. I didn’t want to write about something that on the surface seems simple. However, I have found over the years that few new hikers know what clothes are appropriate to wear in the field. For example, I once went hiking with a person that had never been hiking before. We were planning on entering rough terrain with plenty of noxious plants. I assumed that he would know what to wear. He arrived at the site with tennis shoes, low-rise socks, shorts, and a t-shirt. I told him that he should consider going back to get appropriate clothing. He refused and decided to go forward with the hike. About half way through the hike, he was walking in front of me through a field of thigh high plants on the bank of a creek. I was wearing fairly thick hiking pants and was not paying complete attention to the plants we were walking through. Suddenly, he ran screaming down into the creek and started vigorously rubbing his legs. I looked down at the plants to confirm my immediate suspicion. The plants were stinging nettle and he had walked about 100 yards though them. If he had appropriate clothing, then he would not have been affected by the stinging nettle.

To avoid unpleasant instances like the one described above, I want to give new hikers a brief tutorial on what I use while hiking. Hiking gear can be a very complex and contentious issue. Everyone has an opinion about what is the best gear to have and wear. In reality, it is all about what works best for you. I am a minimalist when it comes to hiking clothes. What I mean by this is I use the minimal amount of clothes for functionality and comfort. I am mostly a warm weather (40˚ F+) hiker/backpacker, so I won’t talk about cold weather clothing here. On a typical summer day while hiking, I will have a pair of lightweight hiking pants, a synthetic shirt, a hat, synthetic socks, a small pack, and a pair of combat boots or hiking shoes (depending on terrain).

I currently have two pairs of lightweight Columbia Sportswear convertible hiking pants. The convertible pants are versatile and allow you to convert from pants to shorts in no time. I must confess that I have never actually converted them to shorts because the fabric is so lightweight and cool that I have never been hot in them, even on the hottest days in summer! The pants are 100% nylon and dry very quickly. Last week I was covered in dew from the saw palmettos I was navigating through. Within 5 minutes of getting out of the palmettos, the pants were completely dry. There are many companies that make synthetic convertible hiking pants. I would recommend getting a good pair.

My choice of shirt has changed radically since I moved to Florida. In Missouri, I would typically wear a cheap partial-synthetic t-shirt. When I say cheap, I mean really cheap! I picked these things up at the local buy-it-all store for $5/5 shirts. The good old days of cheap shirts have passed away for me. Here in Florida I have found copious amounts of mosquitoes that can easily bite through the thin shirts I used to wear. I have switched to vented-back hiking/fishing shirts with rollable long sleeves. The venting and synthetic fiber keeps you cool and the thickness of the shirt repels insect onslaughts. My personal shirts were custom made by the manufacturer and include additional pockets and gizmo holders. In addition, on cooler days I carry a fleece jacket in my pack. I tend to get hot while hiking, so I usually don’t wear it. However, it is nice to have just in case the weather takes a turn for the worse.

Stay tuned for part 3, “Hats, Socks, and Packs”

Nov 032011
 

If you’re anything like me, you really don’t like the bug sprays that contain DEET. In spite of the EPA’s ruling that DEET is safe, there is a great deal of evidence presented by the Cornell Pesticide Information Project and the CDC that would suggest cause for concern. Many people, including myself, have experienced adverse reactions to the chemical. In most cases, I would prefer not to use insect repellent if at all possible. However, Florida has an abundance of mosquitoes. If you don’t use bug spray, then you are asking to be sucked dry. There a number of insect repellent manufacturers that make plant-based “all natural” sprays. These sprays typically contain lemon eucalyptus oil and a plethora of other chemicals. During a recent hike in Upper Hillsborough Preserve I tried two of these products.

Repel Lemon Eucalyptus Insect Repellent
Claimed Effective Time: 6 hours
Actual Effective Time: 10 minutes
Comments: Following proper procedure, I applied this product to exposed areas of skin. It provided a temporary respite to the onslaught of mosquitoes. However, this respite was short-lived and was far from the claims of the manufacturer.

Coleman Botanicals Insect Repellent
Claimed Effective Time: 6 hours
Actual Effective Time: 8 minutes
Comments: This product fared slightly worse than the Repel Lemon Eucalyptus Insect Repellent. However, given that both were exceedingly far from the manufacturers’ claims, the difference was not significant.

Overall Recommendation: I would suggest using physical barriers as your first line of defense against mosquitoes. Wearing pants, long sleeves, and a head net ($2.50 at a local store) over a hat will protect you far better than having to repeatedly apply these insect repellents. With that said, I know it is sometimes inconvenient to wear a head net, especially if you are birding. In those cases, these short-lived repellents are better than the DEET alternative. Just keep the bottle nearby!

Another alternative was recently brought to my attention. It is called 45N68W. I have not yet tried it. You can read about it here and here.

Happy Off-Trailing!